Before you invest in warehouse automation, ask these five questions

Walk the floor at any supply chain automation show today and you will see no shortage of robotics, automation, and AI solutions promising to transform warehouse operations.

Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in the June 2026 edition of MHD Supply Chain News Magazine and is republished here with permission.

From autonomous mobile robots (AMRs) and automated storage and retrieval systems (ASRS), to advanced software and AI-driven planning tools, the options available to supply chain leaders have never been greater.

At the same time, rising labour costs, increasing customer expectations, and ongoing pressure to improve productivity are driving businesses to explore automation opportunities more seriously than ever before.

The challenge is that automation is not a strategy. It is a solution.

Before investing in robotics or warehouse automation, organisations need to understand the problem they are trying to solve. The most successful projects do not start with technology. They start by asking the right questions.

Many organisations can identify revenue by customer, product, or channel, but far fewer understand the true end-to-end cost of servicing that demand.

Without visibility of labour, transport, inventory, and fulfilment costs, it is difficult to determine where automation can deliver genuine value. Understanding your true cost-to-serve often reveals hidden inefficiencies and provides a clearer picture of where investment will generate the strongest return.

Labour remains one of the largest operating costs within supply chains, and attracting and retaining warehouse staff continues to be a challenge for many businesses.

However, labour issues do not automatically justify automation.

Before investing in technology, organisations should examine workflow and process design, travel distances, slotting strategies, and operational processes. In many cases, productivity gains can be achieved through operational improvements, while also creating a stronger foundation for future automation initiatives.

A common mistake is attempting to automate an inefficient process.

Warehouse layouts that were designed years ago may no longer support today’s order profiles, inventory requirements, or service expectations. Congestion, excessive travel, poor storage utilisation, and workflow bottlenecks can significantly impact productivity.

Before introducing robotics or automation, organisations should assess whether their facility is optimised for both current and future demand.

The question should never be: “What automation should we buy?”

Instead, organisations should ask whether they are trying to:

Different challenges require different solutions. The most successful automation projects begin with clearly defined business outcomes and measurable success criteria, rather than a desire to implement the latest technology.

Perhaps the most important question of all.

Many businesses track operational KPIs, but few have an objective view of how effectively their distribution centre is actually performing. Reviewing warehouse design, labour productivity, inventory positioning, technology utilisation, and automation readiness often uncovers opportunities that are difficult to identify through day-to-day operations.

In some cases, robotics and automation will be the right answer. In others, process improvements, layout changes, or technology optimisation may deliver faster and more cost-effective results.

As automation technologies continue to evolve, the organisations achieving the strongest outcomes will be those that take a strategic approach to investment.

The goal is not simply to implement automation.

It is to understand where automation can create the greatest value, support long-term growth, and deliver measurable business outcomes.

Before making your next technology decision, make sure you are asking the right questions first.

Extolla has real people, delivering real results in realistic time frames. Let us help you tackle your supply chain challenges.